Two networks, the same assets

Most people see the power sector as a single network: plants, lines, substations. There is a second one that never shows up on the map: the network of money, made of contracts, the market, system charges and the electricity bill.

The two touch at the same assets. A wind farm is a node in the energy network and a business in the money network. A consumer is a socket in one and a bill in the other. These points of contact are the bridges.

Above both runs a third layer, the events: a lightning strike, an energy surplus, a drought. An event starts at one point and crosses both networks through the bridges. Along the way, the sector's rules decide who pays.

Two networks tied together by the same assets. An event enters at one point and crosses both through the bridges. Two networks tied together by the same assets An event enters at one point and crosses both through the bridges Energy electricity Money contracts and payments Events Rule The wind farm is a node in the energy network and a business in the money network. The hydro plant also has an owner, contracts and revenue. The local grid and the company that runs it and bills for it. The consumer is a socket in one network and a bill in the other. Hydro plant: Generates with water from rivers and reservoirs.Hydro plant Wind farm: Generates with wind; the operator can limit its output.Wind farm Substation: Where lines meet and voltage changes.Substation Transmission line: Carries energy over long distances.Transmission line Distribution grid: Carries energy to every address.Distribution grid Consumer: Home, shop or factory.Consumer Plant owner: The company that sells the plant's energy.Plant owner Contract: A sale agreed in advance, with term and price.Contract Energy trader: Buys and sells energy without generating it.Energy trader Spot market: Settles the gap between contracted and delivered, at the hourly price.Spot market System charges: System costs shared among all consumers.System charges Distribution utility: Buys energy, runs the local grid and issues the bill.Distribution utility Electricity bill: Where energy, grid, charges and taxes reach the consumer.Electricity bill Curtailment reason: The system operator records why it limited each plant.Curtailment reason Who pays: The sector's rules decide whether the loss is refunded, and from which account.Who pays Drought: Below-normal rain in the river basins.Drought Energy surplus: Lots of wind and sun, little demand.Energy surplus Lightning: A strike near a line.Lightning energy network money network event rule bridge: the same asset in both networks Two networks tied together by the same assets. An event enters at one point and crosses both through the bridges. Two networks tied together by the same assets An event enters at one point and crosses both through the bridges Energy electricity Money contracts and payments Events Rule The wind farm is a node in the energy network and a business in the money network. The hydro plant also has an owner, contracts and revenue. The local grid and the company that runs it and bills for it. The consumer is a socket in one network and a bill in the other. Hydro plant: Generates with water from rivers and reservoirs.Hydro plant Wind farm: Generates with wind; the operator can limit its output.Wind farm Substation: Where lines meet and voltage changes.Substation Transmission line: Carries energy over long distances.Transmission line Distribution grid: Carries energy to every address.Distribution grid Consumer: Home, shop or factory.Consumer Plant owner: The company that sells the plant's energy.Plant owner Contract: A sale agreed in advance, with term and price.Contract Energy trader: Buys and sells energy without generating it.Energy trader Spot market: Settles the gap between contracted and delivered, at the hourly price.Spot market System charges: System costs shared among all consumers.System charges Distribution utility: Buys energy, runs the local grid and issues the bill.Distribution utility Electricity bill: Where energy, grid, charges and taxes reach the consumer.Electricity bill Curtailment reason: The system operator records why it limited each plant.Curtailmentreason Who pays: The sector's rules decide whether the loss is refunded, and from which account.Who pays Drought: Below-normal rain in the river basins.Drought Energy surplus: Lots of wind and sun, little demand.Energy surplus Lightning: A strike near a line.Lightning energy network money network event rule bridge: the same asset in both networks
Hover over each point to read what it is. Dotted: a bridge between the two networks.

Three events, three paths

Each column is a layer; each number, a step. A solid line is a link that leaves a record. A dashed one is only closeness in time and on the map, and coinciding is not causing.

Lightning on the line

Lightning on the line. The reason the operator records decides where the value goes. Lightning on the line The reason the operator records decides where the value goes event energy rule money Lightning near the line: Same time, same place: a clue, not proof.1Lightning near the lineSame time, same place: a clue, not proof. The line trips: The record says which line and when.2The line tripsThe record says which line and when. The operator limits the plants: And records the reason. The reason decides the rest.3The operator limits the plantsAnd records the reason. The reason decides the rest. The wind farm generates less: The wind was there; the grid could not carry it.4The wind farm generates lessThe wind was there; the grid could not carry it. The owner sells less: Energy that does not flow is not paid for.5The owner sells lessEnergy that does not flow is not paid for. Or: system-security reason: Under the normal regime nothing comes back: the owner keeps the loss.Or: system-security reasonUnder the normal regime nothing comes back: the owner keeps the loss. Reason: grid unavailable: The rules may refund part of the loss, above an allowance.6Reason: grid unavailableThe rules may refund part of the loss, above an allowance. The refund becomes a charge: All consumers together pay for it.7The refund becomes a chargeAll consumers together pay for it. It reaches the bill: The utility passes the charge on in the tariff.8It reaches the billThe utility passes the charge on in the tariff. recorded link same time and place: a clue, not a cause other branch Lightning on the line. The reason the operator records decides where the value goes. Lightning on the line The reason the operator records decides where the value goes event energy rule money Lightning near the line: Same time, same place: a clue, not proof.1Lightning near the lineSame time, same place: a clue, notproof. The line trips: The record says which line and when.2The line tripsThe record says which line and when. The operator limits the plants: And records the reason. The reason decides the rest.3The operator limits theplantsAnd records the reason. The reasondecides the rest. The wind farm generates less: The wind was there; the grid could not carry it.4The wind farm generates lessThe wind was there; the grid could notcarry it. The owner sells less: Energy that does not flow is not paid for.5The owner sells lessEnergy that does not flow is not paidfor. Or: system-security reason: Under the normal regime nothing comes back: the owner keeps the loss.Or: system-security reasonUnder the normal regime nothing comesback: the owner keeps the loss. Reason: grid unavailable: The rules may refund part of the loss, above an allowance.6Reason: grid unavailableThe rules may refund part of the loss,above an allowance. The refund becomes a charge: All consumers together pay for it.7The refund becomes a chargeAll consumers together pay for it. It reaches the bill: The utility passes the charge on in the tariff.8It reaches the billThe utility passes the charge on inthe tariff. recorded link same time and place: a clue, not a cause other branch
The path splits at the curtailment reason recorded by the operator.

The same cut can end on everyone's electricity bill or as one company's loss. The lightning does not decide that: the reason the operator records does.

Energy surplus

Energy surplus. The same cut as the lightning, another reason, another destination for the money. Energy surplus The same cut as the lightning, another reason, another destination for the money event energy rule money Energy is left over: Lots of wind and sun, little demand. Nothing breaks.1Energy is left overLots of wind and sun, little demand. Nothing breaks. The operator curtails renewables: Recorded reason: energy surplus.2The operator curtails renewablesRecorded reason: energy surplus. The wind farm generates less: The same physical cut as the lightning.3The wind farm generates lessThe same physical cut as the lightning. The rules refund nothing: For this reason, the owner keeps the loss.4The rules refund nothingFor this reason, the owner keeps the loss. The contract still holds: The owner sold energy it did not generate.5The contract still holdsThe owner sold energy it did not generate. The gap goes to the market: Settled in the spot market, at that hour's price.6The gap goes to the marketSettled in the spot market, at that hour's price. The seller bears the risk: Generator or trader: whoever has no slack feels it first.7The seller bears the riskGenerator or trader: whoever has no slack feels it first. recorded link same time and place: a clue, not a cause Energy surplus. The same cut as the lightning, another reason, another destination for the money. Energy surplus The same cut as the lightning, another reason, another destination for the money event energy rule money Energy is left over: Lots of wind and sun, little demand. Nothing breaks.1Energy is left overLots of wind and sun, little demand.Nothing breaks. The operator curtails renewables: Recorded reason: energy surplus.2The operator curtailsrenewablesRecorded reason: energy surplus. The wind farm generates less: The same physical cut as the lightning.3The wind farm generates lessThe same physical cut as thelightning. The rules refund nothing: For this reason, the owner keeps the loss.4The rules refund nothingFor this reason, the owner keeps theloss. The contract still holds: The owner sold energy it did not generate.5The contract still holdsThe owner sold energy it did notgenerate. The gap goes to the market: Settled in the spot market, at that hour's price.6The gap goes to the marketSettled in the spot market, at thathour's price. The seller bears the risk: Generator or trader: whoever has no slack feels it first.7The seller bears the riskGenerator or trader: whoever has noslack feels it first. recorded link same time and place: a clue, not a cause
The same physical cut as the lightning, another reason.

For the plant, nothing changes: it generates less. For the money, everything changes. The seller keeps the loss, and the contract still has to be honoured in the spot market.

Drought

Drought. No equipment fails: the event runs almost only through the money network. Drought No equipment fails: the event runs almost only through the money network event energy rule money Less rain in the basins: A slow event that lasts for months.1Less rain in the basinsA slow event that lasts for months. Hydro plants generate less: Reservoirs fall; dispatch decides how much each plant generates.2Hydro plants generate lessReservoirs fall; dispatch decides how much each plant generates. They share the shortfall: A pooling scheme spreads the water risk among hydro plants.3They share the shortfallA pooling scheme spreads the water risk among hydro plants. The spot price rises: The missing energy gets more expensive.4The spot price risesThe missing energy gets more expensive. Costlier thermal plants start: To save water; the extra cost becomes a charge.5Costlier thermal plants startTo save water; the extra cost becomes a charge. The uncovered pay dearly: Without collateral, a trader can be cut off from the market.6The uncovered pay dearlyWithout collateral, a trader can be cut off from the market. The tariff flag changes: The tariff flag warns consumers of the higher cost.7The tariff flag changesThe tariff flag warns consumers of the higher cost. recorded link same time and place: a clue, not a cause Drought. No equipment fails: the event runs almost only through the money network. Drought No equipment fails: the event runs almost only through the money network event energy rule money Less rain in the basins: A slow event that lasts for months.1Less rain in the basinsA slow event that lasts for months. Hydro plants generate less: Reservoirs fall; dispatch decides how much each plant generates.2Hydro plants generate lessReservoirs fall; dispatch decides howmuch each plant generates. They share the shortfall: A pooling scheme spreads the water risk among hydro plants.3They share the shortfallA pooling scheme spreads the waterrisk among hydro plants. The spot price rises: The missing energy gets more expensive.4The spot price risesThe missing energy gets moreexpensive. Costlier thermal plants start: To save water; the extra cost becomes a charge.5Costlier thermal plantsstartTo save water; the extra cost becomesa charge. The uncovered pay dearly: Without collateral, a trader can be cut off from the market.6The uncovered pay dearlyWithout collateral, a trader can becut off from the market. The tariff flag changes: The tariff flag warns consumers of the higher cost.7The tariff flag changesThe tariff flag warns consumers of thehigher cost. recorded link same time and place: a clue, not a cause
No equipment fails; the event runs almost only through the money network.

A drought trips no line. It makes energy more expensive, squeezes whoever sold without cover and shows up, months later, in the colour of the tariff flag on the bill.

Six questions, six drawings

No drawing shows everything. Each question calls for a view, and all of them read the same graph: the asset lit in one drawing is the same asset lit in the others.

Six questions, six drawings, one selection. Lit in every drawing: the same asset. Six questions, six drawings, one selection Lit in every drawing: the same asset Selected: Transmission line Where? MapWhere?Map How is it connected? Single-line diagramHow is it connected?Single-line diagram Where does it flow? Flow diagramWhere does it flow?Flow diagram Who owns it? Who buys? Ownership treeWho owns it? Who buys?Ownership tree What does it affect? Graph neighbourhoodWhat does it affect?Graph neighbourhood What is happening? Exception feedWhat is happening?Exception feed Six questions, six drawings, one selection. Lit in every drawing: the same asset. Six questions, six drawings, one selection Lit in every drawing: the same asset Selected: Transmission line Where? MapWhere?Map How is it connected? Single-line diagramHow is itconnected?Single-line diagram Where does it flow? Flow diagramWhere does it flow?Flow diagram Who owns it? Who buys? Ownership treeWho owns it? Whobuys?Ownership tree What does it affect? Graph neighbourhoodWhat does itaffect?Graph neighbourhood What is happening? Exception feedWhat is happening?Exception feed
In every drawing, the same asset is lit. Not every asset appears in every drawing.
Question and viewWhere to see it today
Where? MapgridMap
How is it connected? Single-line diagramgridAssets, the page of each substation
Where does it flow? Flow diagramgridAssets, the distribution utility page*
Who owns it? Who buys? Ownership treegridAssets, the plant page and energy traders
What does it affect? Graph neighbourhoodgridAssets, the line page and "Path to the transmission grid" on the plant page
What is happening? Exception feedgridCurt

* in development

To start: in gridAssets, open the page of a substation and scroll to the "Single-line diagram (assembled)" panel. Each line arriving there is an edge of the energy network; the owner of each one is a node of the money network.

How to read the figures, and what we do not claim

How to read

What we do not claim

rede dupla transmissão mercado eventos visualização